We don’t currently have a set of criteria to use when
grading Popular Science novels. However, one of our
recent requests is for one
such book
, specifically Godël, Escher,
. The categories we’re considering for
reviews right now are “originality,” “clarity,”
“structure,” “completeness,” “editing,”
“presentation” (ie. are there pretty pictures?), and
“overall.” Since it’ll likely take me some time to
get through this tome, we might as well give our
readers lots of time to be heard, and we’ll see if we
can reach some sort of consensus.