I tried this out because it was the only Green Lantern trade
on the shelves, and because it was written by Judd Winick.
I’ll be picking up more of Judd Winick’s work on this title
fairly shortly, I assure you.

General Information

Title: Green Lantern: Brother’s Keeper

Author: Judd Winick

Illustrator(s): Dale Eaglesham, most of the time

Original Publication Date: 2003 reprint of material first
published in
2002 (Green Lantern Vol. 2, issues 151-155)

ISBN: 1-4012-0078-8

Cover Price: $12.95 US, $21.95 Can

Buy from: Amazon.com
or Amazon.ca


Kyle Rayner, the latest Green Lantern of Earth, deals with
personal issues culminating in a hate crime against his

High Point

The poster boy for anger management.

Low Point

The fill-in artwork. I’d rather have a late issue than one
that seems
this out of place compared to the rest, especially when it’s
in a trade paperback.

The Scores

This is a pretty original plotline for a comic
book. Most of
the homosexual characters I read about are simply
accepted by those
around them, which is definitely a good thing, but not
realistic. This also provides the kind of challenge that the
superpowers aren’t really able to deal with, which always
adds a twist
to the story. (Where’s the suspense when it can be fixed
on a whim?)
I give it 6 out of 6.

The artwork on any given page is good or very
good, but the
shift between artists is remarkably irritating. I give it 4 out
of 6.

The story is very well written. The focus of the
on the back of the book is about two of the five issues;
keep that in
mind or you may wonder when the “real story” is getting
started. This
was a very interesting look at the life of a superhero and
the trials
he’ll face. I give it 5 out of 6.

The characterization is excellent. This is the
material with Kyle Rayner I’ve read (apart from his tiny
roles in some
JLA books) and his personality is quickly made clear. The
strain on
his personality later really works, too. I feel like I’ve gotten
very good handle on who this character is, particularly
since it’s
only a five issue set. Other characters are less well
defined, but I
still feel like I have some idea of what they’re like. I give it
out of 6.

The emotional response was very strong. I’ve
seen some nasty
things done to gay friends of mine, although none of it was
at this
magnitude. It’s not hard to believe that something like this
happen at any time, and the frustration Kyle felt seems
very, very
real. The transition from the laugh-out-loud funny first
issue to the
final two was well made, preventing any jarring moments
from getting
in the way. I give it 6 out of 6.

The flow was smooth when it was meant to be,
and jarring when
it needed to be. I give it 5 out of 6.

Overall, it’s a highly recommended collection.
It shifts
from pure entertainment into cultural exploration, without
overly preachy. It delves into abuse of power in a way that
I find
more troubling than the Emerald
A very good read. I’d change only the use of a fill-in artist.
I give
it 6 out of 6.

In total, Green Lantern: Brother’s Keeper
receives 37 out of 42.

Additional Notes and Comments

I’ll get back to working on Essential Howard the
Duck Vol. 1

soon. I forgot to bring a book to kill time between exams
today, so I
ended up buying this at the campus bookstore.