Picard Review: Season Two, Episodes 1-6

After a slow start, Picard takes us into far more engaging territory than Season One. It’s derivative, but highly watchable.

Picard, Season Two

Cast and Crew

Directed by Doug Aarniokoski, Lea Thompson, Jonathan Frakes
Written by Akiva Goldsman, Terry Matalas. Christopher Monfette, Michael Chabon, Kiley Rossette, Juliana James, Jane Maggs, Cindy Appel.

Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard
Alison Pill as Dr. Agnes Jurati
Michelle Hurd as Raffi Musiker
Santiago Cabrera as Cristóbal Rios
Jeri Ryan as Seven of Nine
Evan Evagora as Elnor
Annie Wersching as Borg Queen
Penelope Mitchell as Renée Picard
Sol Rodriguez as Dr. Teresa Ramirez
Whoopi Goldberg, Ito Aghayere as Guinan
John de Lancie as Q
Orla Brady as Laris / Tallinn
Brent Spiner as Dr. Adam Soong
Lea Thompson as Dr. Diane Werner
Isa Briones as Kore Soong / Soji
Madeline Wise as Yvette Picard
April Grace as Admiral Whitley
Kay Bess as Voice of La Sirena Computer
Dylan Von Halle as Young Picard
Chloe Wepper as Gabi
Peter Lindstedt as ICE Officer #1
Richard Jin as Moshe
Jon Briones as First Magistrate
Kirk R. Thatcher as Punk on bus who cannot catch a break from time-travelers


Picard and his associates (including the Borg Queen) find themselves in a dystopic future created by an inconsistently-powered Q’s meddling with the past. They return to 2024 to set things right, only to experience more Q meddling, at least two other extraterrestrials on earth, an ancestor of Picard’s, another Soong, and many Easter Eggs.

High Point

The pacing picks up in the third episode and mostly maintains it through to the sixth, with some genuinely interesting mysteries and a bit of fun action to accompany them. It’s a decent story, though it feels padded more often than it does developed.

The initial “social commentary” subplot that occurs with Rios’s injury develops naturally, and represents something Trek hasn’t addressed with past time-travel stories. Sure, McCoy was injured and had no proper I.D. in The City on the Edge of Forever, but that wasn’t especially suspicious in the 1930s. Rios in 2024 faces a bit more of a detour before rejoining the main plot.

Low Point

The initial pacing presents some problems, but I cannot write much more about that, so here I’m going to take a chance:

If they can offer some information for Q’s modus operandi, which has him operating in remote and unlikely ways to accomplish things he could do more easily, I may have to change this Low Point. At this point, however, “I was just testing humanity again in some utterly bizarre way that makes no sense if you think about it for five seconds” won’t fly. John de Lancie is an excellent actor, but I have never shared the effusive fan-love for the character Q. His variable motives and potentially infinite power problematizes the plot and the actual stakes every single time he appears.

In the show’s defense, they hint that Q may be experiencing difficulties with his abilities.

The Scores:

Originality: 1/6 Every SF series revisits the basic premise of The Legion of Time. Here, Trek throws in a good deal of its own time-travel history. To some degree, what we have is an elaborated, labyrinthine revisiting of “Tomorrow is Yesterday” (in particular) and Star Trek IV: The One With the Whales, with more Q and Brent Spiner playing the same old Soong, but with a different name.

Effects: 6/6

Acting: 5/6

Story: 4/6 The story begins at too slow a rate– Star Trek does not always handle the story-arc structure effectively—but picks up considerably after they arrive in 2024.

The writers ask us to accept a few developments on faith. How on earth did our heroes whisk a badly-injured person out of a heavily-guarded secured site to a clinic across town without anyone following them?

Production: 6/6

Emotional Response: 4/6 I am rather enjoying the Easter Eggs, most of which have been incorporated with some subtlety.

Overall: 4/6: This season feels more like Star Trek than the first.

In total, Picard, Season Two, First Half, receives 30/42

4 replies on “Picard Review: Season Two, Episodes 1-6”

  1. Oh look that show that used to show us a hopeful view of the future has traveled to the present day and is lecturing us on all the problems of the “current year” directly. HARD PASS.

  2. I would say it’s more a look at how hard-won that optimistic future is and, yeah, there is social commentary. But the first of those things is an established part of Trek lore and the second has always been a part of Star Trek episodes. TOS was very much a show with social commentary. There are issues with this show, I don’t dispute, but I don’t think either of those are the problem.

    Plot-wise, the major issues (other than Q) are a renegade geneticist, an untrustworthy ally (the Borg Queen), and a pilot who might not make an historic flight that influences the future.

    Also, a landmark forthcoming birthday of mine is, literally, a major turning point in human history so, hey, they clearly got that right. ;)

  3. I am including this week’s episode in my comments:

    The episodes are good, it is fun to watch, but whoever said it was really just glorified fan fiction is very accurate. There’s a lot that doesn’t make sense, but I’ve been quoting Pitch Meeting:
    “If you want to have a great fun story set in 2024 with Picard, I’m gonna need you to get aaaaaaaaaalllllll the way off my back about that.”

    My wife claimed I was being too generous, but I thought the story itself was very well done. (And I had a bunch of whiskey.)

Comments are closed.