Chad writes, Voting has started for the second round, but I still think this would make a good Bureau42 article: http://www.suvudu.com/cagematch.html. I predict it will come down to Gandalf vs. Cthulhu. And anyone who can beat a Balrog can probably whip a Great Old One (even if he dies again in the process).
The problem with these crossover fight set-ups (here, for example )is the characters have different home worlds and ground rules. Harry Potter’s wizards, for example, are ridiculously overpowered, though they do not always use their abilities as well as they could.
I dunno, I’m pretty sure I could take Harry Potter.
Anyone else remember [url=http://www.grudge-match.com/History/index.html]the granddaddy of sites like this[/url]?
Megaweapon, somehow your link got messed up. Here’s the corrected link.
Didn’t Elmer Fudd defeat Cthulhu in the crossover timeline here?
Here.. Fudd and Wile Coyote are seriously underused in these battles. Let’s face it: complete indestructibility trumps actual skill if you’re up against Cthulhu or the Balrog.
Well, à la Samurai Cat, Cthulhu would just throw Elmer Fudd or Wile E. Coyote into orbit—thus winning the match by default.
Well, guess I was completely wrong about the finals. Gandalf lost in round 2, and it looks like Cthulhu will do the same.