The team of Nolan, Goyer and Bale have assembled the final chapter in their Batman saga. It’s got pretty stiff competition from superhero films this summer, as well as competing with the legacy from the first two chapters. Does it make the cut?
Cast and Crew Information
Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne/Batman
Anne Hathaway as Selina Kyle
Michael Caine as Alfred J. Pennyworth
Gary Oldman as Commissioner Gordon
Tom Hardy as Bane
Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Blake
Marion Cotillard as Miranda Tate
Morgan Freeman as Lucius Fox
Matthew Modine as Foley
Written by Jonathan Nolan, Christopher Nolan and David S. Goyer
Directed by Christopher Nolan
The Harvey Dent Act has given the police the power to clean up the streets and wipe organized crime off the face of Gotham. Bane sees this as a problem and seeks to rectify this, forcing Batman to come out of an eight year retirement.
“Kid, are you in for a show tonight!”
Timelines don’t add up in one aspect of the movie that cannot be discussed without a major reveal. DO NOT read the following until you’ve seen the movie. I’m serious. This is a big piece. Miranda Tate has been supporting the clean energy project and the fusion reactor for years. Dr. Pavel, and only Dr. Pavel, knows how to weaponize it, which is what she really wanted it for. Unfortunately, Dr. Pavel’s results were published “six months ago” when the chips are down. Why was she involved prior to that? The publication date needed to be changed to make her sinister character work. I know someone peeked. When you see the film, you’ll be mad you did.
This scores points for originality. Yes, it’s an adaptation, so it won’t get a perfect score, but Nolan took a major risk ending this Batman story the way I doubt any big screen Batman story will end ever again. I give it 5 out of 6.
The effects are excellent. Nolan respects the immersive nature of physical effects and employs far more than most directors would, using CGI primarily to clean up the image of a physical object. I can point to pieces of an image that must be effects and pieces of an image that must be the real thing. At no time can I point to the seam in between them, and at no time did the nature or quality of the effects interfere with the suspension of disbelief. This is exactly what visual effects are supposed to be. I give it 6 out of 6.
The story holds together very well. This team understands something that the Burton/Schumacher team clearly didn’t understand: comic book characters are defined by their characters, and not their powers. Burton and Schumacher gave us a Bane powered by Venom, but Nolan, Goyer and Hardy gave us a Bane that is driven mad by upbringing, and uses a combination of physical strength, cunning, and meticulous planning to achieve his goals. Similarly, this Catwoman is a fully developed character who is true to the comic book interpretation overall, despite never actually using the name “Catwoman.” It also serves as the perfect “third act” to the story started in Batman Begins, but is richly structured enough that it will likely be more satisfying in isolation than, say, The Avengers. The only story issues I see could well be relics of rewriting scene X after filming scene Y and not having time to perform ADR in dialogue referring to time frames to keep things consistent. I give it 5 out of 6.
The acting is difficult to judge. Bale, Caine, Freeman and Oldman are still knocking it out of the park. Hathaway and Gordon-Levitt step into their roles just as comfortably. Hardy was decent, but the nature of his facemask and the sound mixing of his dialogue makes it extremely difficult for him to emote properly. He was never unconvincing, but he had absolutely no chance of having the impact Ledger’s Joker had. I give it 5 out of 6.
The production is extremely well done. This is a team that did it right the first time, and they’ve had two previous films to learn from. They are firing on all cylinders, and have the proven box office track record to justify the 164 minute runtime without being subjecting to being edited down for the sole purpose of getting in an extra screening opening weekend. (See the deleted scenes from Green Lantern or X-Men for examples of what that does to a film.) I give it 6 out of 6.
The emotional response can be summed up as follows: 164 minutes of film felt like it was barely 64 minutes of film, and ends on two incredibly powerful emotional notes. I give it 6 out of 6.
Overall, it’s another chapter in one of the most perfect superhero franchises to hit the big screen. I think it’s too long and too dark in tone to have enough kid appeal to catch up to the box office numbers for The Avengers, but I do think it’s ultimately a better film. I give it 6 out of 6.
In total, The Dark Knight Rises receives 39 out of 42.